Adult Young Adult- The Missing Genre

When I explain my enjoyment of young adult (YA) books, the response is often less than enthusiastic. It can feel like other people’s opinion of me plummets faster than had I said I spend my weekends playing my little pony.

Like a lot of readers, I enjoy a range of genres, yet YA attracts the most cynicism. The older I become, the more YA books feel like my dirty secret, but why? If I said I was reading The Hunger Games then would I be met with such consternation? I doubt it. Yet like so many addictive dystopian reads, The Hunger Games is YA. So what is it about the label YA that draws criticism?

My guess lies in its overly broad nature. YA is not one genre, instead an overarching label applied to many. What dictates it is the age of the protagonist, not the content. The distinction is important because it means that YA books can mean different things to different people. One bad experience reading a vampire story might scar you against the rest of the genre. What is more, the term YA has a juvenile feel to it, lacking the ability to inspire confidence in older readers.

Interestingly though, adults read YA too. Perhaps even more would if not for the attached stigma. A young protagonist is no deter ant to many people’s enjoyment of a good story and there is much about many YA books that grabs a reader’s attention. From fast paced plots to emotion charged scenes, these books can have it all. Some cover the same conflicts as adult novels. Sex, murder, rape, abortion … although the more mature plot-lines are often co-categorised as ‘New Adult’; a warning of the dark content within.

Here are some examples of YA books that are in the same category as Eragon by Christopher Paolini and the Harry Potter series by J. K. Rowling. Would you say that they are all that similar?

YA- New Adult books
Paper Princess by Erin Watt                Reason: Sex scenes
Bully by Penelope Douglas                   Reason: Sex scenes
Going Under by S. Walden                   Reasons: Sex scenes and rape

New adult seems to be a warning label for more vanilla readers, rather than a way of distinguishing the stories that might be enjoyed by adult readers too. Clearly content is not the issue in determining what makes a book YA. So why do I feel guilty reading it? Is there really a difference or are we just in need of more distinction between YA books aimed at young people and those that can be enjoyed by anyone? A new genre might help the issue,providing a label for books targeted at adults too, the same way the genre new adult now helps distinguish the raunchy from the regular. I don’t know about you, but I would love not having to trawl through an entire bookshop before finding a hidden gem.

Here are some examples of YA books I think deserve promoting to adults too. How many more can you think of that deserve another category? If you want to help grow the list then let me know the titles of your recommendations.

Adult YA books (AYA)
Red Rising by Pierce Brown                                 Reason: Amazing plot.
The Raven Boys by Maggie Stiefvater               Reason: Beautiful writing.
The Hunger Games by Suzanne Collins           Reason: Gripping plot.
The Book Thief by Markus Zusak                       Reason: Heart-wrenching story.

One Comment Add yours

  1. I think we should think of YA not at “books for teens” but rather “Easy Reading” or “Commute Reading” or possibly “Entertainment Reading”

    The whole YA concept came about as a marketing strategy to fill a gap between those books written specifically for children and those books written for grown ups.

    Of course there’d been other genres too, Murder Mystery, Crime, Sci-fi, humour, Bodice Rippers, but they were considered somewhat of a backwater until the late 90’s.

    The mainstay of publishing, reviewing, and selling of books was for Adult (i.e. “grown up”) books. Books that were rather worthy. Intricate plots, strange characters, weird often non-nonsensical prose style, page long sentences.

    Difficult to read, follow and understand. The sort of literature where you needed to sit alone at a desk in a half-lit room with a notepad & pencil and regular breaks. This was fine in the pre-radio era when you needed something to fill your time during the oil-lamp hours.

    You know the authors I’m referring to; Joyce, Rushdie, Atwood, Murdoch. Authors that A-level literature students and Undergraduates are forced to read because who-knows-why.

    No one in their right mind is going to read The Handmaid’s Tale for entertainment value or to pass an idle hour. If you’ve got a copy of it open in your hands it’s because you’ve got to read it to pass the course or you’re working on your feminist credentials.

    So the YA genre filled a gap in the market. Books that were once derisively called “Airport Novels”, good story, three dimensional characters, easy to read prose, that allows the reader to enjoy in chunks, i.e. during the commute, lunch break or rainy Sunday afternoon, the sort of thing that people actually enjoy reading. The books no one is ever going to write a doctoral thesis in modern literature on, the stuff that sells.

    A book where the author has done all the heavy lifting for you. Lets stop calling them Young Adult and start calling them what they are:
    Popular Modern Fiction.

    Liked by 1 person

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s